Lesson Plan
Detective Case File
In this 30-minute small-group lesson, students act as detectives to practice CASEL’s Responsible Decision-Making by identifying and evaluating consequences, alternatives, and ethical factors in real-life scenarios. Students will collaborate to analyze decisions, record insights, and reflect on how considering multiple factors leads to wiser choices.
Analyzing real-world scenarios equips students with critical thinking and self-awareness, empowering them to make thoughtful, ethical choices. This lesson develops collaborative reasoning and decision-making skills, supporting students to reflect on potential outcomes and learn from diverse perspectives before acting.
Audience
Time
Approach
Materials
Prep
Prepare Detective Case Materials
10 minutes
Step 1
Detective Briefing & Role Assignment
5 minutes
Step 2
Scenario & Clues Exploration
5 minutes
Step 3
Investigation Journal Analysis
10 minutes
Step 4
Evidence Roundtable & Reflection
10 minutes

Slide Deck
Clues & Consequences
Case Scenario
Analyzing Consequences
Exploring Alternatives
Ethical Considerations
Group Notes & Next Steps

Worksheet


Discussion


Rubric

